This page is an entry in the Key.
TCQ covers BOTH kinds of “trustworthiness,” both “real” (intrinsic) and “perceived.”
1. “Real” (intrinsic) trustworthiness - “Does the photograph deserve viewers’ trust?”
The Trust Checklist ensures that every TCQ-qualified photograph is not unworthy of viewers’ trust.
That’s why photographs that are “deceptive” are disqualified even if they’re not “doctored” (see #515).
2. “Perceived” trustworthiness - “How likely are viewers to trust the photograph?”
The Trust Checklist optimizes the likelihood that viewers will trust TCQ-qualified photographs.
That’s why photographs that are “doctored” are disqualified even if they’re not “deceptive” (see #516)
Trustworthiness, like trust, is a relative term, not an absolute one.
For most photographs and most people, there are degrees of trustworthiness.
The usual levels of trust decrease...
> from photos taken by oneself (or in one’s own presence),
>> to photographs taken by friends one trusts
>> to photographs published by whichever news source one trusts the most
>> to “non-news” photographs that the viewer is confident have all nine characteristics
>> to various other contexts in which photos are trusted less and less (ending in “laughably implausible photos anonymously posted on the Internet”).